DIY move vs. hiring a moving company: Pros and cons

July 15, 2024

Moving house can be one of life’s most stressful experiences, and deciding between a DIY move and hiring a moving company adds to the complexity. Each option has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, which can significantly impact your moving experience. 

This article will help you navigate these choices by exploring the pros and cons of both DIY moves and professional moving services. By understanding the differences, you can make an informed decision that best suits your needs and circumstances.

What is a DIY move?

A DIY move involves handling the entire moving process yourself without the assistance of professional movers. This means you are responsible for packing, loading, transporting, unloading, and unpacking all of your belongings. 

It often includes renting a van or truck, gathering packing supplies, and possibly enlisting the help of friends or family members. DIY moves are common for those looking to save money or those who prefer to have complete control over the moving process.

Pros of a DIY move

Cost savings

One of the most significant advantages of a DIY move is the potential for cost savings. Hiring professional movers can be expensive, with costs including labour, transportation, and insurance. By handling the move yourself, you can avoid these expenses and allocate your budget to other aspects of your move, such as new furniture or home improvements. 

The main costs for a DIY move are typically limited to van rental, fuel, and packing supplies, which can be significantly lower than hiring a moving company.

Flexibility and control over the move

A DIY move offers unparalleled flexibility and control. You can set your own schedule, decide how to pack your belongings, and choose the transportation route. 

This level of control allows you to handle your items with the care and attention they deserve, reducing the risk of damage. Additionally, you can move at your own pace, which can be particularly beneficial if you have a busy schedule or unexpected delays.

Personal handling of belongings

When you move yourself, you have the advantage of personally handling your belongings. This can be especially important for items of sentimental or high value. You can ensure that fragile items are packed securely and that everything is loaded and unloaded with care. 

This personal touch can provide peace of mind, knowing that your possessions are in good hands throughout the move.

Cons of a DIY move

Physical and time demands

A DIY move requires significant physical effort and time. Packing up an entire household, loading heavy furniture and boxes, driving a large vehicle, and then unloading everything at your new home can be exhausting. 

It can also take a considerable amount of time, especially if you have a lot of belongings or are moving a long distance. The physical strain and time commitment can be overwhelming, particularly for those with limited time or physical limitations.

Potential for damage and injury

Without professional training and equipment, the risk of damaging your belongings or injuring yourself is higher in a DIY move. Improper lifting techniques can lead to back injuries, while inadequate packing can result in broken or damaged items. 

Professional movers are trained to handle heavy and fragile items safely, and they have the right tools and equipment to do so. In a DIY move, you may not have the same level of expertise or resources, increasing the likelihood of accidents and damage.

Lack of professional equipment and expertise

Professional movers have access to specialised equipment, such as dollies, straps, and padding, which make the moving process more efficient and safe. They also have the expertise to handle challenging situations, such as navigating narrow staircases or manoeuvring large furniture through tight spaces. 

In a DIY move, you may lack these tools and experience, making the move more difficult and time-consuming. Additionally, you may not have access to insurance coverage for your belongings, leaving you financially vulnerable in case of damage or loss.

What is hiring a moving company?

Hiring a moving company involves enlisting the services of professional movers to handle some or all aspects of your move. This can include packing, loading, transporting, unloading, and even unpacking your belongings. 

Moving companies offer a range of services to suit different needs and budgets, from basic transportation to full-service moves that take care of every detail. Hiring professionals can greatly reduce the stress and physical demands of moving, allowing you to focus on settling into your new home.

Pros of hiring a moving company

Professional expertise and efficiency

One of the main advantages of hiring a moving company is the professional expertise and efficiency they bring to the table. Experienced movers are trained to handle all types of items, from bulky furniture to delicate antiques, with care and precision. 

They know the best packing techniques, how to maximise space in the moving truck, and how to navigate through various challenges. This expertise ensures that your move is completed quickly and smoothly, reducing the risk of damage and delays.

Insurance and protection for belongings

Most reputable moving companies offer insurance coverage for your belongings during the move. This means that if any items are damaged or lost, you can be compensated for their value. 

This added protection provides peace of mind, knowing that your possessions are covered in case of accidents. Additionally, professional movers are held to higher standards of accountability, which encourages them to handle your belongings with the utmost care.

Reduced physical strain and stress

Hiring a moving company significantly reduces the physical strain and stress associated with moving. Professional movers take care of the heavy lifting, loading, and unloading, allowing you to avoid the physical demands of a DIY move. 

This is particularly beneficial for those with physical limitations, busy schedules, or families with young children. By delegating the labour-intensive tasks to professionals, you can focus on other important aspects of your move, such as coordinating utilities and finalising paperwork.

Cons of hiring a moving company

Higher costs

The most significant drawback of hiring a moving company is the cost. Professional moving services can be expensive, especially for long-distance moves or full-service packages. The costs can include labour, transportation, packing materials, and insurance, which can add up quickly. 

For those on a tight budget, the expense of hiring movers may be prohibitive, making a DIY move a more appealing option.

Less control over the moving process

When you hire a moving company, you relinquish some control over the moving process. Professional movers will handle the packing, loading, and transportation of your belongings, which means you may not have as much say in how things are done. 

This can be a disadvantage for those who prefer to have complete control over their move or who have specific preferences for handling their items. Additionally, you will need to coordinate with the moving company’s schedule, which may not always align with your ideal timeline.

Potential for scheduling constraints

Hiring a moving company means working within their availability and schedule. During peak moving seasons, such as summer months or the end of the month, moving companies can be fully booked, making it difficult to secure your preferred moving date. 

This can lead to scheduling constraints and the need for flexibility in your moving plans. If your move is time-sensitive, this lack of control over timing can be a significant drawback.

Factors to consider when choosing

When deciding between a DIY move and hiring a moving company, several factors should be considered:

Distance of the move

The distance of your move can greatly impact your decision. For short, local moves, a DIY approach may be more feasible and cost-effective. However, for long-distance moves, the logistical challenges and physical demands may make hiring a moving company a more practical choice.

Amount and type of belongings

The volume and nature of your belongings are also important considerations. If you have a large number of items or particularly heavy or fragile belongings, professional movers may be better equipped to handle the move safely and efficiently.

Budget constraints

Your budget will play a significant role in your decision. While a DIY move is typically less expensive, the potential for hidden costs, such as damage to belongings or injury, should be considered. On the other hand, hiring a moving company involves a higher upfront cost but can provide peace of mind and convenience.

Personal preference for control vs. convenience

Ultimately, your personal preference for control versus convenience will influence your choice. If you value having complete control over the moving process and are willing to put in the effort, a DIY move may be the right fit. However, if you prefer a stress-free experience and are willing to pay for the convenience, hiring a moving company is likely the better option.

Conclusion

Deciding between a DIY move and hiring a moving company involves weighing the pros and cons of each option. A DIY move can offer cost savings, flexibility, and personal handling of belongings, but it also comes with physical and time demands, potential for damage and injury, and lack of professional equipment and expertise. Hiring a moving company provides professional expertise, insurance protection, and reduced physical strain, but it comes at a higher cost, with less control over the process and potential scheduling constraints. 

By considering factors such as the distance of your move, the amount and type of belongings, budget constraints, and personal preferences, you can make an informed decision that best suits your needs. If you’re considering moving home and need any mortgage advice — contact Sett Mortgages today.

Your home or property may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.